The bank Swimster worked for this summer offered him a full-time position in London and he moves in February. I am so happy for him. I also can't help but feel an ounce of pride knowing we came to New York together, both clueless in our post-undergraduate haze, and despite not being right for each other, neither of us would be where we are today if we hadn't met. You hear, "Things happen for a reason," (most often when things don't happen for you), but after being with Swimster I realized it's not just a cliche, it's real. Swimster, if you're reading this, thank you.
The two of us tried to reconnect for dinner when he got back from London. I wanted to hear about his summer, he wanted to hear about me. I requested we eat Korean because that was one of our favorite meals. Swimster is Korean and it was a treat eating with someone who knew that
bibimbap is not a form of dance but a Korean-style salad
. We finally picked a date and without any further consultation, Swimster told me he made reservations at Chanterelle. I could cut and paste my response here if you don't believe me, but it looked something like this, "&^%$@ Swimster, are you %$#@& crazy!??!" Here I wanted to eat at a hole-in-the-wall Korean place, and he makes reservations for an elegant and expensive dinner. He replied with a sweet message. He's leaving in a few months, it's on his "to do" list before he goes, and I'm the only one who would appreciate it, period.
I got off work that day with a swarm of butterflies. I didn't know what to expect. I'd never had dinner with an ex before. Was conversation going to be awkward? Was I going to have feelings for him? Is he going to ask me about guys? Will I be jealous if he mentions girls? All these thoughts were zipping back and forth in my head. I wanted to see him and get it over with, while hoping the anticipation of seeing him would be worse than the actual event.
I wasn't sure I was on the right block, but when I saw a restaurant with large windows and an elegant dining room I knew it had to be Chanterelle. It was empty except for the waiters in white drifting from table to table, doing the dinner prep waltz, making sure all the final touches were ready for the evening ahead. I walked towards the entrance and spotted a suit with thick black hair. Swimster stood in front of me on his cell phone. I yelled to him and we both smiled and hugged.
Swimster walked me inside and we greeted the hostess. It seemed silly to tell her we had reservations when nobody else was eating but she checked us off her big book and escorted us to our table. It was the best spot in the house: the far corner table with two windows on either side of us. Swimster and I must look important because we are always seated at the "money" tables.
Chanterelle reminded me of Le Bernardin and Jean Georges. There wasn't a lot of decor. It was simple and elegant. The table linens were crisp and the silverware and china glistened in the dim lighting from the chandeliers. I wanted to take it in, but I was also there to take Swimster in. London was great. London was hard. My job is great. My job is hard. I wasn't seeing anyone at the time. He had a really close girl friend in London which made me wonder. We spoke nothing of our past. We focused on the present and the future. It was good for both of us.
Our server came to our table for his official greeting and offered us the wine tome. He seemed more like a creature from "Lord of the Rings" than the man who would wait on us that night. He had tightly buzzed, silver hair, he wore a shiny, silver hoop earring and rectangular spectacles like I'd never seen, and a white goatee trimmed in a perfect isosceles triangle. Not only did he look like he was from Middle-Earth, but his voice even sounded like Gollum. His name was Ed and I'll never forget him.
Swimster ordered a bottle of wine and two servers brought us our amuse bouches. The first plate had two slivers of salmon carpaccio and the other two miniature egg rolls (think pigs-in-a-blanket size). Besides the salmon being chilled and the egg roll being hot, there was nothing spectacular about either. The amuse bouche translated literally means "amuse your mouth." To me, the first thing you taste in a restaurant, whether it be bread, an appetizer, or an amuse bouche should wow you. Swimster and I both agreed, while each tasted like it was supposed to, neither knocked our socks off.
Ed told us we had a choice for dinner. We could order the tasting menu and they would bring us an assortment of plates or we could order dinner a la carte. We chose the latter. For my starter I ordered butternut squash ravioli with oxtail while Swimster chose chef David Waltuck's seafood sausage. The squash ravioli tasted sweet and soft, though a little too soft. The chefs could use a lesson from my Dad on cooking pasta. I tried the ravioli and oxtail in one forkful and it was extremely rich and too powerful together. I decided to eat them separately to enjoy the distinct flavor of each. Swimster's seafood sausage looked like a regular sausage link but it was albino. I looked at it, was a little scared at the sight of it, but dug a fork in. I thought the idea was better than the taste.
For our main meals Swimster tried the pork loin and I tried the filet with oysters and mushrooms. The pork loin was soft and tender. Swimster was happy. My filet was perfectly medium rare and I barely needed my steak knife to cut the soft piece of meat. They were too generous with the mushroom sauce, however, which is saying a lot because I usually drown filets in sauce whether it's poivre or bearnaise. When oysters are served, you want to be able to taste them, and the poor guys were overpowered by the thick mushroom sauce.
Our server returned to the table with dessert menus, and while we couldn't think of fitting anything else in our stomachs, we wanted to go the distance, and try all we could at Chanterelle. Thank goodness we did. Dessert at Chanterelle is worth the visit itself. It was the highlight of the feast. To give you an idea there's no cookbook for the restaurant Chanterelle (not counting Staff Meals), but there is a cookbook for the desserts The Sweet Life and one of the servers was kind enough to bring me the cookbook. We ordered one thing each, but we ended up getting a lot more. Swimster chose the apple dessert which came in two parts: one part apple cake and one part stuffed baked apple. I dug my fork into both and "mmm-ed" for five minutes chewing on the soft warm cake and the crisp baked apple. I chose the chocolate tarte in hazelnut crust. My tarte was a thick mousse wrapped in a hazelnut crust. The crust was crumbly-my favorite crust. I felt we were in Beauty and the Beast. Servers came by our table dropping off goodies one right after the other in a sort of dessert train. First we got the main desserts, then a dish of candies, followed by a tea tray of cookies. My only wish is they served them in a little container to take home. We were so stuffed we couldn't appreciate them all.
Swimster and I left Chanterelle with full stomachs and smiles. We were not completely blown away by dinner, but it was a special night nonetheless. After I said goodbye to Swimster, I turned around and watched him cross the street, wiping away tears. We broke up so many months ago, and I didn't have feelings for him anymore. Where were the tears coming from? I guess I just missed him. I missed us. I missed having someone. Chanterelle, along with many other restaurants we ate at, will hold a special place in my heart. And I believe for the rest of my life, whenever I bite into a nice filet or a piece of cheese, I will think to myself, "Swimster would love this."
2 Harrison St., between Hudson & Greenwich Streets
212-966-6960
to keep reading